How you can enhance critical thinking in multicultural teams

Did you know that 89% of white-collar employees work in virtual teams? A recent survey revealed this fact. It showcases that the world of modern work presents everyone with new challenges that require new ways of thinking and communicating.

The flexibility that comes with working remotely means your virtual teams often include team members from diverse cultural backgrounds. Chances are you face team environments that are unique in a way that can interfere with your team’s ability to solve complex problems effectively. 

Diversity holds immense potential for innovation and creativity. But how can you enhance critical thinking in this multicultural setting? Today, I want to introduce you to some problem-solving approaches and ways you can provide the right kind of supportive environment so your team members have their needs met and feel their ideas are appreciated and valued. 

Understand the many sides of challenges and solutions for multicultural teams

For teams from different cultures to excel in complex problem-solving, it's important to understand and deal with challenges that arise from communication barriers, cultural differences, and lack of trust. Let's explore what you can pay attention to:

1. Build trust

Trust is the foundation of open conversation and sharing ideas, which fuels critical thinking and innovation. Without trust, ideas don't flow freely, and the team can't reach its full potential.

How you build trust might be different from how each team member builds trust. Recognising two key cultural differences is key to creating an inclusive environment where trust can grow:

• Trust Based on Personal Relationships and Familiarity: In some cultures, trust grows from long-term personal relationships and a strong sense of knowing each other well. Here, trust is more about the bonds connecting team members personally than just their skills.
• Trust Based on Competence and Achievements: In some other cultures, trust is built from proven abilities and accomplishments. Personal relationships might not be as important as what each person has achieved and can bring to the table. 

Respecting both ways of building trust will help your team collaborate better and fuel capacity for critical thinking.

2. Build psychological safety 

Psychological safety helps your team members have the courage to share their unique ideas and concerns. That makes it a cornerstone for high performance in multicultural teams. Timothy Clarke has a great model that explains the four stages of psychological safety that are crucial for team development. Each of the stages is influenced by cultural differences:

1. Inclusion Safety: Inclusion safety meets your basic need to connect and feel like you belong. In multicultural teams, this means respecting and including everyone's diverse backgrounds, making sure each team member feels valued and accepted. (In virtual teams, this can be tricky because people might not have met face to face.)
2. Learner Safety: Learner safety encourages you to actively join in learning activities. Different cultures have different learning styles—whether through group discussions or studying alone (see deductive and inductive thinking styles*). Recognising these styles helps create an environment where everyone can learn and contribute.
3. Contributor Safety: Contributor safety allows you to use your skills and make important contributions. Understanding the different ways cultures approach contribution, from focusing on group harmony to individual achievement, can boost the team's ability to work together and think critically.
4. Challenger Safety: Challenger safety gives you the confidence to question the status quo and suggest changes. This stage needs an understanding of how different cultures view hierarchy and disagreement. It creates a space where challenging ideas is not only safe but encouraged, leading to continuous improvement. (In some cultures with high power distance, it's not easy to challenge your superior, and in collectivist cultures, keeping harmony is often more important than challenging others.)

Recognising and respecting these stages and cultural differences helps build a team where everyone feels safe to share, learn, contribute, and challenge, leading to an inclusive, more effective team.

Start from trust and psychological safety and you will notice how much more naturally critical thinking comes for a team where everyone’s perspectives and concerns are heard and valued. 

3. Explore different problem-solving approaches

Different cultures have unique ways of solving problems. Understanding these differences can help you and your team find the best solutions together.

Uncertainty Avoidance

Cultures vary in how much they like clear rules and certainty.

• High Uncertainty Avoidance: These cultures prefer clear rules and structured approaches to problem-solving. They like knowing exactly what to do and having everything planned out.
• Low Uncertainty Avoidance: These cultures are more comfortable with uncertainty and trying new, unconventional methods. They don’t mind a bit of chaos and are open to exploring different ways to solve problems.

These two cultural dimensions are key because they lead to different ways of thinking and solving problems:

Thinking Styles

• Deductive Thinking Style (high uncertainty avoidance): This top-down approach starts with a general theory or hypothesis and moves towards specific observations. If your culture prefers deductive reasoning, you might excel in situations that need a clear framework and direction.
• Inductive Thinking Style (low uncertainty avoidance): This bottom-up approach begins with specific observations and builds towards general conclusions. If your culture leans towards inductive reasoning, you might thrive in environments that encourage exploration and innovation.

Exploring and understanding these different problem-solving approaches is essential, as you need both ways of thinking to reach the best results. Skillfully combining them can be one of the secrets to why many teams are so efficient.

4. Address communication barriers

Communication in multicultural teams can be tricky on many levels. Let’s look at some common barriers:

Language

When team members speak different languages, misunderstandings and incomplete information can occur more easily. Even subtle nuances in communication styles can lead to misinterpretations, which can affect the team’s performance and problem-solving abilities. To enhance everyone’s well-being and happiness, it’s important to create an environment where language diversity is seen as a strength, not a problem.

There are also different communication styles that are interpreted differently in different cultures:

Low Context vs. High Context Communication Styles

• High-Context Communication: relies a lot on implicit messages, nonverbal cues, and shared understanding, which is common in collectivistic cultures that are relationship-oriented. 
• Low-Context Communication: explicit, direct, and clear, often found in individualistic task-oriented cultures. The skill to read between the lines is not so developed, as the expectation is for clear expressions.  

Assertive vs. Reflective Communication

• Assertive Communication: confident and direct, allowing you to express your ideas and opinions openly. 
• Reflective Communication: involves listening, understanding, and considering others' perspectives before responding.

Recognising and adapting to these different styles can help prevent miscommunication and ensure effective teamwork. These skills are essential for critical thinking in a multicultural team.

How to overcome challenges in critical thinking and problem-solving?

Solving problems in multicultural teams can be tough because different cultures have different expectations about who makes decisions.

In some cultures, people expect managers to make all the key decisions. In other cultures, everyone gets a say. If some team members expect managers to decide, it is important to explain why involving everyone in decision-making is helpful. Solving complex problems is easier when you get ideas from different people.

By understanding and addressing these cultural challenges, you can create a team environment that encourages open dialogue and values everyone's perspectives. This helps the team work together better and think more critically, aiming for global excellence and performance.

InCultures understands these challenges and offers solutions to build cultural intelligence, helping every team member feel valued and heard.

Through leadership development and team excellence programs, InCultures empowers teams to use their diverse ways of thinking and develop culturally acceptable ways to share real opinions. This helps avoid groupthink and encourages open dialogue.

It's time to take action. Build your team's cultural intelligence and adopt new critical thinking tools for better problem-solving. Develop a high-performing culture that supports your strategy.

Are you wondering if your team is reaching its full potential? Find out with InCultures’ Global Team Success Indicator assessment. This free tool gives you a detailed look at how your team is doing right now and shows you where you can improve to unlock your team's true potential.

Follow Pia on LinkedIn for her latest insights, and join our newsletter for regular updates on how to cultivate a thriving, culturally intelligent team environment.

Here are a few of our other articles you might be interested in:

Six key dimensions for aligning diverse teams and breaking barriers in multicultural environments

Working Dilemmas Framework: How to Measure Organisational and Team Culture Effectively?

Cultural Adaptability: The Key to Thriving in a Multicultural Environment